Hiking With A Dog?

[mochilero]

An informal poll: How many of you think t's okay to hike with a dog?

I have a friend that always hikes with her German Shepherd, which makes sense for a single woman in an area of cougers and bears. I have another friend who thinks dogs just shouldn't be allowed in the wilderness. I suppose they can be noisy, chase wildlife, and harrass other hikers, but then humans do those things too. I don't have a dog, by the way. Just curious how people feel about the issue.

Steve

http://www.TheBackpackingSite.com

[ga2ski]

we take our dog, part lab, part keshihound (sp?). She loves it. For the most part she is good, but she does chase squirrels and chipmunks. I don't think that is a big deal if she chases the rodenst but wopuld be pissed if she chased bears, deer moose etc. She sometimes barks at people mainly men, especially ones with trekking poles, so i can see why people may not like dogs.

just my opinion.

[thetrailboss]

I recall seeing something about this in here...or at least I thought.

I've got no problem with dogs...granted that 9

(a) They are leashed and do not bother native animals or plants

(b) They are respectful of other hikers and folks and are quiet,

and

(c) The owners CARRY OUT their waste...but seeing how well my neighbors do this part, I am skeptical

So, if those are met, I have no problem

[ctenidae]

I wouldn't hike with a dog in an area where there is heavy traffic, mostly because I wouldn't want to keep it on a leash. Or hike in places with heavy traffic, for that matter. Can't get on board with packing out waste. You don't pack your own out, do you? Or clean up after bears? That being said, people who let their dogs crap on the path really annoy me. I don't see the dogs hurting plants or animals any more than humans (particularly) or other wild animals.
I use to hike with my old German Shorthaired (RIP), and he was great- he stayed on the path until something caught his attention, then he'd head off into the woods, but always came back up to the path in the exact same place he left it. Never figured out how (or why) he did that. I loved having him along- quiet, obedient, and my best friend. My current dog, I'd never take hiking. He's big, obnoxious, and unpredictable. At least, in comparison to Ben he is...

[severine]

We hike with our dog (a cocker spaniel). She LOVES being out on the trail. We keep her on leash in heavy traffic areas, but will let her go off-leash in areas where we're not likely to run into anyone (she never goes more than maybe 15 ft ahead, then stops and waits for us). I don't see anything wrong with it, as long as the dog is well-behaved. I also have to agree with ctenidae, though, on the packing out thing. If we're at a regular walking path, we do... but if we're on a trail, we just make sure she doesn't go on the trail (and if she does, we're sure to move it). After all, I wouldn't pack out my own "waste."

[pedxing]

Well behaved dogs on the trail are fine with me. I do think dog owners should take care of the dog's waste, but I see no need to pack it out under circumstances that I wouldn't pack out my own.

I'd also add that dogs shouldn't be in shelters where other people are, especially if the dogs are wet, if a person could use the space, or others in the shelter aren't asked for permission.

[riverc0il]

I have a friend that always hikes with her German Shepherd, which makes sense for a single woman in an area of cougers and bears.

perhaps it is different in new england, but we have bears and moose in this neck of the woods that do everything they can to avoid people. i do not think bringing a dog along for protection is logical, i think animals will fear people more than they would fear dogs. and if the dog gets aggressive with an animal normally inclined to pass by a human, you could actually create a situation where there may not have been one before.

Can't get on board with packing out waste. You don't pack your own out, do you? Or clean up after bears? That being said, people who let their dogs crap on the path really annoy me.

leave no trace policy states you should pack out both your own waste and your pet's waste. i am not a stickler on LNT on this item so long as the waste is no where near a trail and any TP used is packed out for people. my memory is foggy on this topic, but i think you can also burry it a certain depth.

TB has great points, but i would add one more: dog owners who think their dog is friendly and who think their dog is under voice control should:

a: carry a leash for high traffic areas and USE IT.

b: see dogs from the point of view of a non-dog owner that is being hassled by a dog. often times owners are too narrow minded to see someone else's point of view. if your dog is disrupting someone else's day, that's a problem. you, as a fellow human being, wouldn't run up to a stranger, jump on them, and start licking them would you? if your dog does so, or starts barking at other dogs, they are not as much under your control as you think they are, or you as an owner aren't exerting enough control if your dog starts effecting other people in ways they do not like. again, you have to see the perception of a non-dog owner. i know so many dog owners that think everyone loves dogs. especially theirs.

all that said, i enjoy seeing dogs on the trails and if i ever decide to own a dog, i would find a dog with a temperment and activeness that might enjoy some hiking.

[smitty77]

I'm hiking with my dog more and more these days, but we hike in an area close to home and early in the morning, where I may pass only 3 hikers on the 4 mile loop. She's a husky, so she makes a great speed hiking / trail running companion. She maintains a high pace and doesn't like to take long breaks, so she's been great for my fitness. I always keep her leashed as I'm not too confident in her ability to stay in the same zipcode as myself. She loves to run, and really loves to chase small furry creatures, so I keep her on a 6 foot lead to minimize her impact on the surrounding wildlife.

She also gets quite excited when we see other hikers with dogs, so I do my best to pull her aside and keep her in a sitting position until they pass. The more people that are present, the more she gets excited. I don't take her on crowded trails for this reason. Some people get a little nervous when they see my bundle of energy doing flips at the end of the lesh and standing on her hind legs. She's getting better every week, but she still has quite a bit of "puppy" in her. At least she doesn't bark, not even at other dogs. I don't pack out her waste, but I do make sure it is well clear of the trail and try to dig a small hole with the heel of my boot (if possible) and bury/cover it.

Smitty

[Dugan]

I am strongly in favor of hiking with dogs. My pooch rarely stays home. Although he probably scares away some wildlife, by watching his actions, I also see many things I otherwise would not have noticed.

However, if, as you say, a dog is harassing others (wildlife, hikers, or dogs), then the handler is at fault. Unfortunately, just as there are irresponsible hikers, there are irresponsible dog owners.

[Snowflower]

perhaps it is different in new england, but we have bears and moose in this neck of the woods that do everything they can to avoid people. i do not think bringing a dog along for protection is logical

As a female New Englander who often hikes alone I have to say that I always bring my dog along for protection...not from bears and moose, but from men. I just feel way more comfortable having her with me than hiking alone...even though she's way to friendly to be much of a bodyguard!