wow- I am gone one day and the world changes. I voted no- for many of the reasons stated. I am intimidated enough posting here as a noski (the nerve!) and am more comfortable at skiMRV where I feel more closely connected and am shown with my name and job title. I didn't, and don't, see the benefit of a system like this in a forum where people are respectful, helpful, and fun.
However, I will say: "REPS TO YOU!!" for launching a thread that has seen so much action in a time of year there is not much else to talk about! Brilliant move.
edit: and thank you Greg for continuing to look for ways to make this forum fun, inviting, interesting, and moving forward- even if this one didn't work!