• Welcome to AlpineZone, the largest online community of skiers and snowboarders in the Northeast!

    You may have to REGISTER before you can post. Registering is FREE, gets rid of the majority of advertisements, and lets you participate in giveaways and other AlpineZone events!

The "New" Gore-tex

Puck it

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 26, 2006
Messages
9,681
Points
48
Location
Franconia, NH
The expiration of the gore tex patent in 1997 really did not bring anything down. Why would this?
 

C-Rex

New member
Joined
Mar 4, 2010
Messages
1,350
Points
0
Location
Enfield, CT
Competition will help, but I think the big reason Gore-Tex hasn't come down much is simply brand recognition. People know Gore-Tex is the real deal, and trusting another brand can be sketchy. It's hard to tell if it'll have the same performance so people are still willing to pay for the Gore-Tex label. The ski industry, in general, isn't as picky about gear, but the people who really guide this technology - climbers- don't eff around. The reliability of their gear can be the difference between life and death. However, opinions will change over time as other products become proven.

This stuff is interesting though. I'd imagine having the membrane built into the fabric also makes it more durable. It's hard to imagine something more lightweight and flexible than Gore-Tex. My 2L [AK] jacket is amazing. Cheers to these guys for raising the bar.
 

Cannonball

New member
Joined
Oct 18, 2007
Messages
3,669
Points
0
Location
This user has been deleted
Competition will help, but I think the big reason Gore-Tex hasn't come down much is simply brand recognition. People know Gore-Tex is the real deal, and trusting another brand can be sketchy. It's hard to tell if it'll have the same performance so people are still willing to pay for the Gore-Tex label. The ski industry, in general, isn't as picky about gear, but the people who really guide this technology - climbers- don't eff around. The reliability of their gear can be the difference between life and death. However, opinions will change over time as other products become proven.

This stuff is interesting though. I'd imagine having the membrane built into the fabric also makes it more durable. It's hard to imagine something more lightweight and flexible than Gore-Tex. My 2L [AK] jacket is amazing. Cheers to these guys for raising the bar.

Exactly this^. I've bought several pieces of expensive non Gore-tex gear in the past that claimed to have the same performance. They didn't. After losing a half day of prime riding at Snowbird because my pants failed to be waterproof and I was soaked and frozen, I swore not to ever deviate from Gore-tex again.

It would be great to see some other materials that perform just as well and create more options. But I'll need some real convincing to choose other than Gore-tex.
 

C-Rex

New member
Joined
Mar 4, 2010
Messages
1,350
Points
0
Location
Enfield, CT
I have some CandyGrind gloves that are leather with a knock-off Gore-Tex liner, and they actually work quite well. But I definitely have seen it go your way too. With something like pants or a jacket, I'd have to be very sure I was getting a quality product. Glove aren't as big of a deal, especially with leather where I can just Nikwax the shit out of them to keep them dry. I think its Patagonia that has the H2NO Gore-Tex replicant. I've heard that one works pretty well.
 

Puck it

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 26, 2006
Messages
9,681
Points
48
Location
Franconia, NH
Most companies are now using non Gore tex products. Most use the Polartec version.
 

prsboogie

Active member
Joined
Aug 13, 2014
Messages
1,764
Points
38
Location
Swansea
"Patagonia that has the H2NO Gore-Tex replicant. I've heard that one works pretty well."

It works great so far on my Snowshot shell, I have to see how it holds up over time. Only been out in really wet conditions 4-5 days so far.
 

Bumpsis

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 25, 2004
Messages
1,088
Points
48
Location
Boston, MA
I was never too impressed with Goretex as a waterproof barrier, nor it being all that breathable. My ski pants are are Gortex and my bum will still get soggy if the chair is wet. I also have a Goretex rain jacket which in the rain, still results in my back being wet. It could be due to perspiration but either way, the claim of being waterproof/breathable is questionable at best. Even a brisk walk in the rain will result in me being almost just as wet as if I did not have the jacket on.

I found that without the proper coating of the Goretex garment , the water penetration - or at least, my own inside jacket wetness under outside wet condition increases drastically. So, when the coating wears off, the membrane all by itself doesn't do much. Where Goretex shines is in the wind protection - on that it really delivers.
 

C-Rex

New member
Joined
Mar 4, 2010
Messages
1,350
Points
0
Location
Enfield, CT
I was never too impressed with Goretex as a waterproof barrier, nor it being all that breathable. My ski pants are are Gortex and my bum will still get soggy if the chair is wet. I also have a Goretex rain jacket which in the rain, still results in my back being wet. It could be due to perspiration but either way, the claim of being waterproof/breathable is questionable at best. Even a brisk walk in the rain will result in me being almost just as wet as if I did not have the jacket on.

I found that without the proper coating of the Goretex garment , the water penetration - or at least, my own inside jacket wetness under outside wet condition increases drastically. So, when the coating wears off, the membrane all by itself doesn't do much. Where Goretex shines is in the wind protection - on that it really delivers.

Gore-Tex is only waterproof when the moisture can bead up. If you smear it onto the fabric the surface tension breaks and the molecules can pass through the barrier. That's why you can still get wet when you sit in a wet spot or if you get super drenched. I'd love a pair of Gore-Tex pants with a non-breathable, fully waterproof patch on the seat and the knees/thighs. And a Gore-Tex jacket with fully waterproof patches on the shoulders. Those are really the only spots that I notice getting wet in really soggy conditions. Helly Hansen had a few jackets like that IRRC.
 

jrmagic

New member
Joined
Mar 9, 2009
Messages
1,939
Points
0
Location
Hartsdale NY/Londonderry VT
Aside from the waterproof aspect one needs to consider durability as well. Gore tex Pro she'll is pretty bomber material. Will the new lighter and thinner fabric hold up as well when bushwhacking etc?
 

C-Rex

New member
Joined
Mar 4, 2010
Messages
1,350
Points
0
Location
Enfield, CT
That is certainly part of it but read the link I posted and see the other piece of the puzzle.

Very interesting, and it makes a lot of sense looking back. If the patent expired in 1997, why haven't more companies gone to cheaper alternatives, or invented their own version. I guess we have an answer. Gore-Tex is basically using their popularity to bully companies into sticking with them. And since no alternative (to date, anyway) has been proven more waterproof and/or breathable it's hard to get people to switch away from what they know and love.
 

SnowRock

Active member
Joined
Oct 16, 2012
Messages
320
Points
28
Location
Jersey City, NJ
Interesting article here back in 2012 but still relative reguarding Gore tex dominance and competition.
http://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-gear/Insane-in-the-Membrane.html
I guess I shouldn't be surprized at a huge company using strong arm tactics.

Definitely interesting... I have an old eVent Jacket from EMS that I used for a few years including a Whistler trip with lots of snow and some rain mid to lower elevations and it worked damn well. My current pants are Mountain Hardware using the DryQ eVent stuff and though I am one of those rare snowboarders that does not spend much time on my rear, I have found them to work really well over the past two seasons. My jacket is a patagonia with H2no and I notice no real performance difference versus my old gore tex shell. I do always splurge for gore tex mittens, but outside of those I don't know if its worth the premium anymore.
 
Top