• Welcome to AlpineZone, the largest online community of skiers and snowboarders in the Northeast!

    You may have to REGISTER before you can post. Registering is FREE, gets rid of the majority of advertisements, and lets you participate in giveaways and other AlpineZone events!

Private Political Discussion Forum?

Should we add a private political discussion forum?

  • Yes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Not sure

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0

Greg

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Jul 1, 2001
Messages
31,154
Points
0
What is everyone's thoughts on having a private political discussion forum here? All members would be welcome to join the group that would be provided access if they so desire, but those not interested in politics can simply not join and would not even see the forum as a result.

I see a number of benefits. For example, this would cut out the political noise from the Miscellaneous Forum. Any new threads in Miscellaneous that evolve into a political discussion can be moved and instructions on how to join the group to continue the discussion would be posted. Another benefit is these heated political threads would not be indexed by the search engines so we would not see folks registering here just to flame. Finally, from a moderation standpoint, it adds a nice layer whereby problem users can be removed from the group and thus denied access to the political forum, but not banned entirely from the forum proper.

Some may question whether a political forum would be out of place here. Remember, not long ago, we decided to shelve the Mountain Bike Forum idea because it would make AZ 'too broad'. As always, I'm reluctant to add additional forums, but I feel the pros outweigh the cons here especially since this forum will be of an 'opt-in' nature. Again, it won't even be visible to guests and members that don't join the group. Thoughts?
 

pizza

New member
Joined
Jan 26, 2004
Messages
259
Points
0
Location
Suffern, NY/Times Square/Killington, VT
Website
www.tursi.com
All boards get political discussions, and this board is no different. The question you should ask yourself as the administrator is this: Does a dedicated politics discussion further the purpose of the board? I don't think so, and that's why I voted "no." These political discussions are relatively few and far between here (note I said "relatively") and are easy to avoid by those not interested.
 

ChileMass

Active member
Joined
Nov 10, 2003
Messages
2,482
Points
38
Location
East/Central MA
I think it's a good idea. As several people have said, all boards get some political action, and if we have a dedicated political "parking lot" we can dump these arguments in there and leave everyone else out of it. Plus, these things can be fun - I think everyone who's been involved the past couple of days would agree. Hell, even dmc and Stephen managed to make up..... :wink: :wink: :wink:
 

Jaytrek57

New member
Joined
Aug 27, 2003
Messages
207
Points
0
Location
Blue Hills, MA
I vote no.

Why not a Sports forum, Music, or (insert topic here) forum?

I like AZ b/c it is a bit looser than some other sites. I try to stay out of the "political" threads as much as possible, but from time to time I might be drawn in. Being raised Irish Catholic, you learn not to talk religion or politics at social functions :wink: . And well I guess this bulletin board in way provides that for me.

Anyone who has spent any time at backpacker.com can tell you that, that BBS is ALL over the freaking place. I would hate to see that happen to AZ.

Save the "politics" for other sites, which I am sure there are plenty. Let's have more hiking, skiing and outdoor related discussions.

JMHO! :beer:
 

Stephen

New member
Joined
Sep 4, 2002
Messages
1,213
Points
0
Location
Somersworth, NH
Website
www.dunhom.com
I used to visit AMC all the time, but the M&M sucked me in to so many discussions, that I never had time to visit the rest of the site. I'm sure it's a great resource, but I have no desire to go back after my experiences in the politcal discussions.

I voted yes, as it provides a layer of distance between AZ and what could be construed as "over the top" comments (of which I myself have even been guilty of).

-Stephen
 

riverc0il

New member
Joined
Jul 10, 2001
Messages
13,039
Points
0
Location
Ashland, NH
Website
www.thesnowway.com
i think most of us participating in the political discussions may have gone over the top on comments at times. politics is something so many people feel very passionite about and topics do tend to generate strong responses. AZ's political topics though have been sticking very close to the issues and have not gone south the way mountains and molehills on AMC forums went. i think the community hear has a high level of respect for those that we have disagreements with which is a big difference between flaming matches and AMC M&M style discussions. i do not think a seperate forum would result in that type of M&M issues and there seems to be enough chatter in the Misc forum to warrent it. i also hate seeing a board break down into too many sub-divisions, but i think the number of related posts may warrent it. whereas when the mountain bike forum came up, hardly any mountain bike posts are ever made or if they are, they do not merit a lot of comments and views.
 

SilentCal

Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
450
Points
16
Location
Western Mass
I voted yes. I started the thread on gasoline prices and it's subject matter got turned around so completely that after a page or two, you did not know what the orginal post was about. While it's truly amusing to read the banter back and forth, sometimes it just gets a little bit out of whack. It's so amusing to read the apologies to each other when you know dammed well they are saying "that guy is a total !@#$^ moron". I feel the way that some people cut each other up is such outstanding comedy that you should regulate it because of it's venom.

The regular people who come here for basic information on skiing or hiking don't need to be subjected to that kind of banter. Maybe after 15 posts the politcal thread could be unlocked for you if you choose. I'm sure there have been politcal posters who neither hike nor ski but just post to get attention.
 

pizza

New member
Joined
Jan 26, 2004
Messages
259
Points
0
Location
Suffern, NY/Times Square/Killington, VT
Website
www.tursi.com
How about an "everything else" forum?
This is where you post any message that isn't related to a forum that already exists. That would include politics, music, and pro sports.

It solves the problem without altering the direction of the web site.
 

Stephen

New member
Joined
Sep 4, 2002
Messages
1,213
Points
0
Location
Somersworth, NH
Website
www.dunhom.com
pizza said:
How about an "everything else" forum?
This is where you post any message that isn't related to a forum that already exists. That would include politics, music, and pro sports.

It solves the problem without altering the direction of the web site.

That was the original intent of the misc forum. However political threads make up more than have of the misc now... and the other half seem to turn politcal at one point or another.

I think what Greg is trying to offer may be an alternative to nixing politcal discussions, as they can be overbearing and hijack an otherwise legitimate discussion (as was pointed out above).

To use the Mtn Bike example, I'm sure if over half the threads in the misc forum were about mountain biking, we'd be pretty quick to channel that into it's own forum.

-Stephen
 

Greg

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Jul 1, 2001
Messages
31,154
Points
0
Stephen said:
That was the original intent of the misc forum. However political threads make up more than have of the misc now... and the other half seem to turn politcal at one point or another.
Correct. And remember, this proposed solution results in a forum that will only be visible to those that "subscribe" to it. Also, it keeps our poly threads out of the search engines so we don't attract folks who just want to flame or troll and aren't even interested in Northeast skiing or hiking.

Stephen said:
I think what Greg is trying to offer may be an alternative to nixing politcal discussions, as they can be overbearing and hijack an otherwise legitimate discussion (as was pointed out above).
Again, correct. Darren over at VFTT runs a very tight ship and doesn't allow any discusson of politics nor virtually any else not related to the subject of Northeast hiking. I don't like this approach as I feel getting viewpoints on other matters from like-minded local skiers and hikers realy adds to the camaraderie found here.

Stephen said:
To use the Mtn Bike example, I'm sure if over half the threads in the misc forum were about mountain biking, we'd be pretty quick to channel that into it's own forum.
Again, correct. There are only a couple of biking/mtn biking threads and none of them received any replies...
 

Joshua B

Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2003
Messages
946
Points
16
Location
Hudson, MA
Has anyone PMd you to say they took offense to the current political discussions?

I usually avoid them but I think they're fine staying the the General board.
 

ctenidae

Active member
Joined
Nov 11, 2004
Messages
8,959
Points
38
Location
SW Connecticut
I think the biggest advantage to a dedicated politics thread is keeping it off the search engine index- that helps maintain the hiking/skiing aspect, so that guests adn new members come to AZ for that (avoiding the flame-only members).
I look at this board kind of like a neighborhood bar- a bunch of people who know each other pretty well, sitting around talking about stuff. Mostly we talk about skiing and hiking, because that's what we all ahve in common, but we wander a bit, just like any bar. A politics-only thread is kind of like a dark booth in the back, where you know what the conversationis, and if you don't want to get involved, no problem.
 

Greg

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Jul 1, 2001
Messages
31,154
Points
0
Joshua B said:
Has anyone PMd you to say they took offense to the current political discussions?

I usually avoid them but I think they're fine staying the the General board.
No. No complaints made to me. It was simply proposed privately among the moderators.
 

BeanoNYC

Active member
Joined
Feb 6, 2005
Messages
5,080
Points
38
Location
Long Island, NY
I voted "not sure"

I like Greg's reasons for the private political forum but I can't help but think that this will end up being an opportunity for some heavy flames. At least if it is out in the public, there is some sort of self monitoring going on. In a private forum, it may well end up like an OK-Corral and undermining relationships between members (I'd hate to see someone miss a meetup because of hard feelings) and the overall spirit of the forum (the vibe here is cool and I'm afraid a shooting gallery would mess with it.)

Rich
 

Vortex

Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2004
Messages
458
Points
18
Location
Canterbury NH, Bethel Me
ctenidae said:
I think the biggest advantage to a dedicated politics thread is keeping it off the search engine index- that helps maintain the hiking/skiing aspect, so that guests adn new members come to AZ for that (avoiding the flame-only members).
I look at this board kind of like a neighborhood bar- a bunch of people who know each other pretty well, sitting around talking about stuff. Mostly we talk about skiing and hiking, because that's what we all ahve in common, but we wander a bit, just like any bar. A politics-only thread is kind of like a dark booth in the back, where you know what the conversationis, and if you don't want to get involved, no problem.

I could have not said this better. I voted yes and I will not enter the potential new forum. I like the core topics. New members should come here for skiing and hiking. I favor a mountain bike froum, but we would need more people involved.
 

smitty77

New member
Joined
Aug 8, 2003
Messages
654
Points
0
Location
Athol, MA
Website
hotmix77.tripod.com
My vote was also for "not sure". I think leaving the political discussion in Misc are fine. That's part of what that forum is for - anything not pertaining to hiking or skiing.

But, having the ability to "mask" these posts from the outside world would be nice, it keeps the riff-raff out.

Smitty
 

bvibert

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Aug 30, 2004
Messages
30,394
Points
38
Location
Torrington, CT
What if you just made the Misc section only viewable for registered members? That would eliminate the search engine, riff-raff thing...
 

bvibert

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Aug 30, 2004
Messages
30,394
Points
38
Location
Torrington, CT
I don't know much about search engine indexing, but if having a separate forum for politics that is only viewable by certain members will stop those posts from being indexed then the same should work for the misc discussion if it was only viewable for members. If you don't want people finding this site because of the political discussions then you probably don't want them to find this place based on the misc-discussions in general
 
Top