American Idol - Season 10

[andyzee]

ANDY : I like that final 3 too . Haley's voice timbre is unique and she looks 'jes fine !

She's looks great, voice is good, damn, she does that Adele song better than Adele and she's got great stage presence, nice little swagger going. As far as I'm concerned, Pia had nothing on her.

 

[Warp Daddy]

Jacob goes home , Lauren Alaina and Scotty are the bottom 3

James once again steals the show

 

[gmcunni]

i started watching late so i need to go back but my thoughts-

james locked up top 2 if not the whole thing
haley good as usual
casey - didn't like.. the angry casey showed up again (haven't seen since he was saved) and it was not appealing to me.

 

[Puck it]

jacob out!!!!!!

 

[gmcunni]

jacob out!!!!!!

Yes please.

 

[Warp Daddy]

Surprised by this result !! I KNOW the jazz constituency is smaller than the country one but apparently Jacobs support was bigger than i imagined .

CasEy in my mind was way more versatile AS BOTH A MUSICIAN AND AS A SINGER .

Glad James and Haley breezed in tho

 

[gmcunni]

ryan ruined it (again) by way he opened the show, that told me it was Casey. no doubt he's an incredible talent, just not popular enough and i don't think his angry growling does him any favors with the average voter.. still shocked that Jacob wasn't gone though.

 

[Warp Daddy]

ryan ruined it (again) by way he opened the show, that told me it was Casey. no doubt he's an incredible talent, just not popular enough and i don't think his angry growling does him any favors with the average voter.. still shocked that Jacob wasn't gone though.

Agree Seachrest is a tool ! His pedantic attitude pisses me off at times . he isn't the show or the talent

Jacob leaves next week !

 

[campgottagopee]

Thanks for the update....was stuck in the 19th hole watching the draft, not that that's a bad thing.:beer:

 

[Warp Daddy]

Jacob goes -------------------------------but i honestly felt all the performance TONITE were spot on !!!

It's getting really interesting now !

 

[Puck it]

He has to go.

 

[gmcunni]

with Warp - jacob out

Haley was great, i liked the first number even tho the judges didn't

james and haley will be top 2. i prefer james but haley will be the next american idol.

 

[Warp Daddy]

with Warp - jacob out

Haley was great, i liked the first number even tho the judges didn't

james and haley will be top 2. i prefer james but haley will be the next american idol.

I think Haley's first number was GREAT !! The judge's were off wall on their feedback

Still lovin James ,But damn Haley is really peaking

 

[campgottagopee]

I concur…Jacob=gone…James, well he my pick of the litter. Haley filleted that first song, killed it---judges were right out of their chickens with their comments. I’ll add this…if Scotty were “cool” he’d have a shot at this thing, but too much geek in that boy to be a star. I did like his first tune...kinda country rock...38 Special anyone???

 

[gmcunni]

I think Haley's first number was GREAT !! The judge's were off wall on their feedback

i actually do agree with part of what the judges said, song selection matters. at this point (and ever for the past several weeks) it is very important to connect with the audience and singing obscure songs we've never heard of doesn't, IMHO, do that. i'm a big proponent of singing well known songs that people can relate to and putting a twist on it.

BUT last night with Haley's first song she took that rule and threw it out the window. She is in it to win it, dawg!

 

[gmcunni]

and her 2nd song was pretty good too!

 

[Warp Daddy]

Yeah and she KNOWS damn well win lose is NOT the goal now -- IF she CONNECTS with Iovine

 

[SkiFanE]

Yeah and she KNOWS damn well win lose is NOT the goal now -- IF she CONNECTS with Iovine

He may have competition from Steven Tyler...he seems to really like Haley, like, really really like her.

 

[gmcunni]

He may have competition from Steven Tyler...he seems to really like Haley, like, really really like her.

my wife, who reads the gossipy stuff, says Haley and Casey are "together".

 

[campgottagopee]

my wife, who reads the gossipy stuff, says Haley and Casey are "together".

Casey b a lucky boy