Smuggs has built its reputation over many years as VT’s top family destination ski resort. It also has the advantage of being only an hour from Burlington which serves as a draw for college students and locals with reasonably priced season passes. Burke is close to two hours from Burlington and there are too many mountains closer to Burlington that draw from that population ahead of Burke.
I think that last 3 or 4 owners have hoped to make Burke “a mecca for families from the Boston metro area” but there are too many mountains that have already captured that market. I don’t think that a HSQ and a shared pass with Jay Peak – which is still another hour drive – is going to do much to get “wealthy skiing families from Boston” to buy vacation homes there.
As a UVM alum, I can tell you very few of the student skiers I knew got passes at Smuggs. Most got passes to Stowe or Sugarbush. The Burlington Metro area is also only about 200K residents. Compare that with what? 3.5M in Metro Boston? Heck, metro Manchester, NH is more than twice the size of metro Burlington and only two hours away. While I'm sure Smuggs generates a fair amount of local business, their bread and butter is traveling destination skiers filling their condos in the village.
I disagree that just because Burke hasn't been successful at drawing in second home owners from Boston in the past, doesn't mean they can't be successful at it in the future. I kind of look it at from my own family's experience. The first few years as a skiing family we skied primarily Killington. We tried Okemo the 1st year the Northeast Summit Triple went in. My folks chose to buy real estate there as it was less expensive than Killington and they saw Okemo as up and coming. Now look at the place.
I think with upgrades to their snowmaking and improving their lodging offering, Burke can very much steal family ski business from not just Smuggs, but Sugarbush and Stowe in VT and perhaps Sunday River and Sugarloaf in ME as well. The commute is so much easier to Burke than any of those other destinations. They just haven't had a developer with deep enough pockets to make it happen. It would appear that now they do in Stenger/Jay.