MEtoVTSkier
Active member
That's gonna be a LOT of generators to take care of all those ventilators and other medical equipment. The temporary hospital set-ups probabaly won't have big systems, if any, like real hospitals.
Welcome to AlpineZone, the largest online community of skiers and snowboarders in the Northeast!
You may have to REGISTER before you can post. Registering is FREE, gets rid of the majority of advertisements, and lets you participate in giveaways and other AlpineZone events!
No country/state/province/city is going to stock half a billion $ worth of ventilators just in case. In addition, ventilators is just one of the many things which would be needed to prepare for a pandemic. Ventilators would be useless for an haemorrhagic ebola-like fever for example. This link is just a terrible, tendentious piece of crap.
The temporary hospitals in NH aren't meant for the advanced, severe cases. They are designed and set up for lighter cases to unload the full hospitals for the most severely ill.That's gonna be a LOT of generators to take care of all those ventilators and other medical equipment. The temporary hospital set-ups probabaly won't have big systems, if any, like real hospitals.
View attachment 26638
That’s a lot on ventilators!!!!!
Whenever you’re in a hospital if you see a red outlet. That’s emergency power.
My point is not that should not have prepared. The point is that if the cost to get prepared is several billions of $ (half a billion just for ventilators) just in case something like this happens, this would be an impossible sell for any politicians. And you should really ask if these billions of $ would be put to a much better use to save more lives in the mean time. In addition, the truth is that nobody has prepared for this so blaming New-York is cheap and counterproductive. It's cheap politics. There are lots of reasons why New-York is hit first. It's going to hit the Bible belt eventually and I hope nobody will do cheap politics when their health care system is overloaded.The ventilators are just one example of the states lack of preparedness. And if they had listened to the report and stockpiled supplies as they were told they needed vs wasting money on other things, they would have saved money because they wouldn't be paying well over sticker price for everything as they are now. The state screwed up and now wants the federal government to bail them out
My point is not that should not have prepared. The point is that if the cost to get prepared is several billions of $ (half a billion just for ventilators) just in case something like this happens, this would be an impossible sell for any politicians. And you should really ask if these billions of $ would be put to a much better use to save more lives in the mean time. In addition, the truth is that nobody has prepared for this so blaming New-York is cheap and counterproductive. It's cheap politics. There are lots of reasons why New-York is hit first. It's going to hit the Bible belt eventually and I hope nobody will do cheap politics when their health care system is overloaded.
My point is not that should not have prepared. The point is that if the cost to get prepared is several billions of $ (half a billion just for ventilators) just in case something like this happens, this would be an impossible sell for any politicians. And you should really ask if these billions of $ would be put to a much better use to save more lives in the mean time. In addition, the truth is that nobody has prepared for this so blaming New-York is cheap and counterproductive. It's cheap politics. There are lots of reasons why New-York is hit first. It's going to hit the Bible belt eventually and I hope nobody will do cheap politics when their health care system is overloaded.
But cuomo whining about trump not being prepared is counterproductive as well.
Sent from my iPhone using AlpineZone
My point is not that should not have prepared. The point is that if the cost to get prepared is several billions of $ (half a billion just for ventilators) just in case something like this happens, this would be an impossible sell for any politicians. And you should really ask if these billions of $ would be put to a much better use to save more lives in the mean time. In addition, the truth is that nobody has prepared for this so blaming New-York is cheap and counterproductive. It's cheap politics. There are lots of reasons why New-York is hit first. It's going to hit the Bible belt eventually and I hope nobody will do cheap politics when their health care system is overloaded.
This is true...the sad fact is that nobody in the USA was prepared for this.
Our "leaders" on both sides of the aisle failed miserably at the most important job they are sworn to do...protect the American people. It seems it's the last thing any of them care about.
Pandemic preparedness and response should start and end with the Fed because this is a national issue. Hell, its a global issue. Remember, the US was pretty much the reason Ebola didn't get out of control.
Do you really want to rely on a poor state such as Mississippi calling their own shots when they can't afford to do the right thing and their inaction might screw everywhere else? One of our richest states couldn't get it done right and things are going haywire because of it.
The shortage of supplies with PPE and Ventilator technology to have acceptable strategic reserves could very easily be managed through a public/private partnership.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using AlpineZone mobile app
This is very much a federal issue. That way a larger (much larger) pool of resources can be distributed to where it is needed most when it is needed. That is what we do now with most natural disasters. To expect states to independently be prepared for every impending distasteful is incredibly inefficient and just pits one state against another. Oh wait, that’s what we’re doing now with supplies and it’s a train wreck. This state by state BS on what aid you get from the feds, and the commentary that comes with it, has grown old over the last 3 years. In situations like this, we are one nation, not a collection of red and blue states. It would be nice if our leadership saw it that way.
The states certainly have more intimate knowledge of their town to town/city to city population and needs than the Feds do.
The Feds have more resources at their disposal that the states do
I agree with this, but this pandemic has made me realize there's an inherent problem here. The states are likely going to ask for more then they need, either to be conservative, or for a politician to cover his ass, and this will stress that supply system.
Real world example happening now: Cuomo keeps going on TV saying that NYC needs 30,000 ventilators. Nobody I've seen once has ever questioned this, but it seems nearly impossible in a city of 8.6M people given only about 5% will require ICU treatment, and the fact that not 100% of ICU patients will require vent. The infection rate would have to dramatically increase from where it is now, which seems highly unlikely given NYC has gone from completely ignoring COVID19 to now taking it seriously. So lets say NYC winds up needing 17,000 vents and you do provide them the 30,000 requested; well that's a HUGE problem for numerous other places in America if you misallocate 13,000 ventilators.
I agree with this, but this pandemic has made me realize there's an inherent problem here. The states are likely going to ask for more then they need, either to be conservative, or for a politician to cover his ass, and this will stress that supply system.
Real world example happening now: Cuomo keeps going on TV saying that NYC needs 30,000 ventilators. Nobody I've seen once has ever questioned this, but it seems nearly impossible in a city of 8.6M people given only about 5% will require ICU treatment, and the fact that not 100% of ICU patients will require vent. The infection rate would have to dramatically increase from where it is now, which seems highly unlikely given NYC has gone from completely ignoring COVID19 to now taking it seriously. So lets say NYC winds up needing 17,000 vents and you do provide them the 30,000 requested; well that's a HUGE problem for numerous other places in America if you misallocate 13,000 ventilators.
This fucken bullshit is killing our best healthcare people that are trying the best to serve patients.
Why all you debate everyone here maybe your right about governor combo or wrong really don't matter in times like these is from my cousin who work in NYC hospital
"We don’t have enough tests for patients or staff. The system is ramping up, but we have known exposures and staff are being told to keep working unless they become symptomatic.
This bullshit might inspire me to finally go get a firearm, something I have always maintained I would never do.