I'd be interested in seeing what their opening date history is. After being away a very long time I'm back with Attitash/WC as my primary mountain.
It is interesting that Loon had a strong opening 1 full month before Atittash, by virtue of location I know Lincoln is better suited to day trippers- but a full month?, we have a relatively short season. I think that is significant.
I think you nailed it regarding Loon being a Day Trip area, where as the MWV areas are more of a "destination." Most of the people I've encountered over the years in the MWV tend to be either locals or second home owners. You don't run into many people heading up to Wildcat from Boston for the day. Loon is a totally different story.
Regarding Boyne areas opening a full month before Peaks area; I guess it's just a difference in operating philosophies. I think Boyne realizes they will always be in a dog fight with Killington in terms of cornering a large percentage of the Boston market. A few years ago, Peaks was aggressive with opening Mount Snow early, but they've since backed off.
It does seem crazy to me that Attitash doesn't push hard to open for Thanksgiving weekend due to the real estate development at the mountain. If I were a condo owner there, I'd probably be upset. Then again, the vast majority of skiers don't think of skiing until Christmas week.
Honestly, I don't mind too much that Peaks doesn't push hard for early season product. In a way, I think it's healthier for early and late season ski operations in the east to have fewer mountains going for it. There are only so many of us diehards who look to get out as soon as possible in late October and Early November. Same goes for the spring side of the season. If every major area made a push to get open early in the fall and stay open late into the spring, it would dilute the profitability across all areas. I'm fine with Killington and Sunday River cornering the early season market. They usually offer good values and I enjoy starting my season at one or the other (usually both) through mid-December before I move on to where I have a pass for the season. That's been the case for me when I was a pass holder at Ragged for a couple years, Gunstock for a couple years and now this season going with the Granite pass. I viewed skiing yesterday at Crotched as a bonus. I wouldn't have had a problem going to Sunday River, Loon or Killington if Crotched or Wildcat weren't open.
As long as Crotched and Attitash make major efforts to have as much terrain open as possible for Christmas week through the end of March, I'm happy with that. Wildcat I always have low expectations for early season until the natural snow starts coming. Peaks can announce how much they've invested in snowmaking there on the front page of the New York Times if they wanted, but I don't expect anytying major. However, I do have high expectations that they operate Wildcat until May 1st. It's one of the best spring skiing mountains in the East and being right across the street from the premier hike to skiing in the east, I think they should push out the season through April. Most years they do.