Scruffy
Active member
Looks like a fine mountain to me. Steep, decent vertical, couple fast lifts, 150" of natural and convenient to the NYC folks. I'm sure I'd ski there often if I lived in that metro. Platty likely a bit more depending on recent natural.
I hit Hunter a lot because I'm in the Catskills often. It skis much bigger and tougher than it is on paper. Of course this depends on conditions, so yeah, if someone has been there only once and there was nothing challenging open at that time, then you might have a poor opinion of it. The locals have a saying: If you can ski there, you can ski anywhere. There is some truth to it.
But people, really you shouldn't go there, the lack of NYC, and Northern Jersey crowds alone will make you want to run to Killington where you'll see much more of them. :-D