Tipsdown,
I'm going to have kindly disagree with your assessment of Saddleback's vert. I think the trails at Sunday River ski longer than Saddleback because for the most part, I think people don't link the top of Saddleback with the rest of the mountain on a given run. You're either skiing the Kennabago Chair or the Rangely Double for the most part; 960 vert and 1177 vert respectively.
The runs at Sunday River ski quite a bit longer to me. I agree that the 2300 vert claim is a farse, even though you can ski it all if you so chose. That said, a number of Sunday River's pods do afford longer runs over more vertical than Saddleback. Jordan, Barker/Locke and Whitecap all ski longer than the Rangely trail pod.
Deadheadskier,
I can't argue with you there. The outdated lift system at Saddleback hurts the potential for longer runs. I know that's something they plan to address and I'm factoring in the proposed lifts as part of my assessment. But in its current state, you're right, unless people do link the top of the mountain to the base area. If you look at the 10 year plan, they're be doing a lot of development below the Kennebego chair will translate to alot of continueous vertical.