I realize Katahdin isn't burke, but the same principles apply, and I agree with Mike's post wholeheartedly, but jesus guys, its not like hiking is some olympic endeavor, we were climbing katahdin for high school trips, and the subsequent 10 hikes around the southern baxter park peaks were all just that, hikes and experiences, did I make to all the peaks, no, but because of respect for the mountains and weather and trail conditions, and my preperation, or lack there of, everyone chimes in to say this poor guy is likely going die or need rescue, have half the people even been up there?, its comical the folks that make it to the top, or even attempt it, but thats what its about - the liklihood of this guy jumping of the knife's edge is pretty low
its sad to hear the stories of people perishing in the mountains, but thats why we go, because things are different up there, the energy put into it, the power they possess, have a little respect and common sense, I'll leave it at that
To answer your question, yes I hiked Katahdin last year. And if you read the initial post, the guy in question has no serious hiking experience and does not even own hiking boots. You and I probably grew up hiking and being outside everyday, so it may not seem like a big deal to handle a mountain like this because it comes as second nature. But if you want to advise a guy who doesn't even own hiking boots to take on Katahdin for his first hike, be my guest. I'd rather be overcautious.