Jully
Active member
Playing in a marching band is great experience, but is nothing like getting together with a few of your friends and creating something entirely new.
I've shared the stage with a lot of different guys. Never did I play with anyone who was in a high school band for 4 years. Probably a year at most, if at all. Now does this mean band will ruin your creativity and make you a follower? Probably a mixed bag of correlation. A mad man drummer will probably want to play more like John Bonham than John Souza.
Can't argue with your assertion that high school band is nothing like creating a song with a group of friends (especially speaking as someone who never participated in high school band but still plays music with friends as frequently as I did in college). I guess I always viewed it as a self selecting crowd, but I've known kids that play in HS band AND play on their own. Best drummer I've ever played with was firmly entrenched in marching band as well. Those that enjoyed playing music in that structured environment were drawn to HS band and those that wanted more freedom did their own thing.
Of course I have no way of showing this beyond my feelings and anecdotes so you very well could be right.
Last edited: