You've yet to answer one question that's been asked at least a few times; Have you ever even been to Magic?
I also asked in the other thread regarding Magic's pricing. No response yet, which considering his strong opinion of the area, I too am curious about his experiences there to lead to such an opinion.
Again, snowman, how much experience do you have skiing Magic? How often and when was the last time you visited?
Based upon what you value in a resort - high lift and snowmaking capacity, long vert, all the cush amenities, yeah you might not like it there. But have you skied there enough to form an opinion? Just asking